Quality

Most quality problems are not random. They are produced by conditions that are out of standard, a setting that has drifted, a material that has changed, a method that has been modified without anyone noticing. The Quality pillar builds the capability to find those conditions and remove them.


Most sites have a quality system. They have procedures, inspection points, release criteria, and a team responsible for making sure the product meets the standard before it leaves.

What most sites do not have is a clear picture of where their defects are coming from.

The defects are recorded. The rejects are counted. The rework is done. But the conditions that produced the defect, the equipment setting that drifted, the material that changed, the method that was modified, are often not investigated. The defect is managed. The cause is not removed. And so the defect returns, on the next batch, or the one after that, or three months later when the same condition recurs.

A quality system that records defects without eliminating their causes is a system that has learned to live with them.

The Quality pillar is built on a different premise. A defect is not a random event. It is produced by a condition. Find the condition, correct it, and confirm it stays corrected. That is the work.


Pillar Intent

The Quality pillar exists to build the capability to define what good looks like, make defects visible before they leave the process, and eliminate the conditions that keep producing them.

That is not an inspection function. Inspection finds defects after they have been made. The Quality pillar works upstream, on the conditions that produce defects in the first place. Equipment settings. Material standards. Method consistency. The four conditions that must be right for the process to produce a consistent result: the right person, with the right method, using the right material, on equipment in the right condition.

When all four are defined, monitored, and confirmed, defects become rare. When any one of them is undefined, unmonitored, or drifting, defects become predictable. The Quality pillar makes that predictability visible, and then removes it.

This pillar works in close partnership with Autonomous Maintenance and Problem Solving. AM Step 6 is where quality control standards are built into the operating team's daily inspection routine, the team learns which equipment settings affect which quality parameters, and monitors them as part of their standard work. The Quality pillar defines those standards. Problem Solving provides the investigation discipline when a defect occurs. The Quality pillar applies that discipline specifically to defects, using the four conditions as the structured analysis lens.


Pillar Owned Losses

Quality losses are not always directly visible on a loss report. Some are obvious, a batch rejected, a line stopped for a quality hold, a customer complaint. Others are hidden inside the numbers that everyone accepts as normal.

⚠️
Defects, rework, and rejects. Product that does not meet the standard. Some is reworked. Some is rejected. Some leaves the site and becomes a complaint. The cost of each individual event is visible. The cost of the condition that keeps producing them is not, because nobody has added it up.
⚠️
Quality holds and investigations. Product held pending investigation. The hold is the visible cost. The invisible cost is the production schedule disruption, the working capital tied up in held stock, and the management time consumed by an investigation that would not have been needed if the condition had been found earlier.
⚠️
Customer and consumer complaints. Defects that reached the customer. The complaint is the signal. The defect that caused it was produced earlier, in the process, by a condition that was not detected or not corrected. Every complaint is a defect that the internal quality system did not catch.
⚠️
Process variation that produces inconsistent output. The product is within specification, but not consistently. Some batches are better than others. Some shifts produce more rework than others. The variation is real, it is just not large enough to trigger a rejection. It is absorbed by the team as normal. It is not normal. It is a signal that one or more of the four conditions is not under control.
⚠️
Hidden losses from overfill and overuse. Product given away to compensate for variation. A fill weight set above the nominal to ensure the minimum is always met. A coating weight increased to ensure coverage despite inconsistent application. The giveaway is real and it compounds across every batch. It is rarely connected to quality, because the product passes. But it is a quality loss, a cost produced by a process that is not capable of hitting the target consistently.
⚠️
The cost of managing defects rather than eliminating them. Inspection points added to catch a defect that keeps recurring. Rework steps built into the process to correct a problem that was never solved. Operators who have learned to adjust for a condition that should not exist. These are not quality systems. They are workarounds. They cost time, resource, and attention, and they make the real cause harder to find, because the workaround is absorbing the signal.

Pillar Owned Processes

The Quality pillar owns three processes. They are introduced in sequence. The Product Defect Matrix tells you where to focus. Quality Defect Investigation removes the cause. Quality Control Standards prevent the defect from returning.

Product Defect Matrix. The starting point. A structured classification of defects by type, severity, frequency, and the sub-process or equipment that produces them. The matrix makes the defect picture visible across the site or function, and it drives the prioritisation of investigation and improvement work. Without it, effort goes to the most recent defect, not the most significant one.

Quality Defect Investigation. The process for finding and eliminating the root condition behind a defect. It uses the same six-stage problem solving discipline used across the site, Define, Return to Standard, Understand Why, Select the Solution, Validate the Fix, Make it Stick, with the four conditions (Man, Machine, Material, Method) as the structured analysis lens. A defect investigation that does not examine all four conditions has not finished the investigation.

Quality Control Standards. The documented connection between process conditions and product quality. For each critical quality parameter, the standard specifies: which equipment setting or process condition affects it, what the correct value is, what the acceptable range is, how it is monitored, at what frequency, and what to do when it drifts. These standards are integrated into the operating team's inspection routine at AM Step 6. The Quality pillar defines them. AM owns the monitoring.


Pillar Behaviours

A defect is found during production.

Without the system: The batch is held. The defect is recorded. The product is reworked or rejected. The line restarts. The same defect occurs on the next batch. The team adjusts the process slightly. The defect reduces. Nobody investigates the condition that produced it.
With the system: The defect is recorded and classified against the Product Defect Matrix. If it is a known type, the quality control standard for that parameter is checked, was the condition within standard when the defect occurred? If yes, the standard needs to be reviewed. If no, the condition is corrected and confirmed. If it is a new type, or a recurring type without a completed investigation, a Quality Defect Investigation is opened. The defect does not recur without a finding.

A quality control standard is introduced at AM Step 6.

Without the system: The standard is documented. It is added to the inspection checklist. The team checks the setting at the start of each shift. When the setting is found outside the range, they adjust it and record the adjustment. Nobody asks why it keeps drifting.
With the system: The standard is built with the team. They understand which quality parameter it affects and what happens to the product when the setting drifts. When the setting is found outside the range, the adjustment is made, and the frequency of drift is tracked. A setting that drifts consistently is a signal that the standard is wrong, the equipment is deteriorating, or the method for setting it is not reliable. The Quality pillar investigates. The drift is not accepted as normal.

A customer complaint is received.

Without the system: The complaint is investigated. The batch is traced. The product is assessed. A corrective action is raised. The corrective action closes the complaint. The same defect type appears in a complaint six months later.
With the system: The complaint is investigated and the defect is classified. The investigation asks: was this defect type visible in the internal data before it reached the customer? If yes, why did the internal system not catch it? If no, what condition produced a defect that the internal system could not detect? The finding changes either the quality control standard, the inspection point, or the process condition. The complaint is not just closed. The system is improved.

The Product Defect Matrix is reviewed at the monthly quality review.

Without the system: The top defect types are listed. The counts are compared to last month. The team discusses whether the numbers are acceptable. The meeting ends. The same types appear next month.
With the system: The top defect types are reviewed against open investigations. Every type in the top five has either a completed investigation with a confirmed fix, or an open investigation with a named owner and a due date. A type that has been in the top five for three consecutive months without a completed investigation is escalated. The matrix is not a reporting tool. It is a prioritisation tool. The question is not what the numbers are. It is what the investigations have found.

What Good Looks Like

Quality team member (pillar team)

  • Maintains the Product Defect Matrix. Reviews it monthly and ensures the top defect types have active investigations or confirmed fixes.
  • Leads or supports Quality Defect Investigations on the highest-priority defect types. Uses the six-stage process and the four conditions as the structured analysis lens.
  • Builds quality control standards in partnership with the operating team and the Maintenance function. Does not write standards in isolation and hand them over. Builds them with the people who will monitor them.
  • Reviews quality control standards regularly. A standard that is consistently found outside its range is a standard that needs to be examined, not enforced.
  • Is present at the AM Step 6 work on each line. Brings knowledge of which quality parameters are most affected by equipment condition. Ensures the quality control standards built at Step 6 are correct and complete.
  • Connects quality data to the TAM agenda. The quality score belongs in the daily meeting, not only in the monthly quality review.

Frontline leader (in areas with quality control standards)

  • Confirms quality control standards as part of the Process Confirmation routine. Not a separate quality check, part of the same confirmation that covers the CIL and Centreline standards.
  • When a setting is found outside the standard, corrects it and records it. Does not accept drift as normal. If the same setting drifts repeatedly, raises it as a quality investigation, not just a recurring adjustment.
  • Ensures the team understands the quality control standards they monitor, which parameter each one affects, and what happens to the product when it drifts. A team that monitors a setting without understanding why will stop monitoring it when the audit pressure drops.
  • When a defect occurs, asks the right first question: was the process in standard when the defect was produced? That question determines whether the investigation starts with the standard or with the condition.

Operations leader

  • Ensures quality defect investigations are completed, not just opened. A named owner and a due date are not enough. The investigation needs a finding that has changed something.
  • Reviews the Product Defect Matrix at the monthly quality review. Asks: what have the investigations found? Not: what are the numbers?
  • Supports the Quality pillar team's access to the line for investigation work. A defect investigation that cannot get to the equipment is an investigation that will not find the cause.
  • Connects quality performance to the site's strategic objectives. A defect rate that is not improving is a strategic problem, not just a quality metric.

Site or function leader

  • Sets the expectation that defects are investigated, not managed. A rework step that has been in the process for two years is not a quality system. It is a workaround for a cause that has not been found.
  • Asks in reviews: what are our top three defect types this month, and what have the investigations found? Not: what is our defect rate?
  • Ensures the Quality pillar team has the resource and the access to do investigation work. An investigation that is always deprioritised by production pressure will never finish.
  • Connects the Quality pillar to the AM programme. Asks AM teams what quality control standards they are monitoring and whether they understand what they are for. The question signals that quality is not the quality team's problem alone.

Audits and Confirmations

✅
Is the Product Defect Matrix current and being used to prioritise? A matrix that is updated monthly and reviewed at the quality meeting is a reporting tool. A matrix where every top defect type has a named investigation owner and a due date is a prioritisation tool. The difference is whether the data is driving action or describing it.
✅
Does every recurring defect type have a completed investigation? A defect type that appears in the top five for three consecutive months without a completed investigation has been accepted. That is a management decision, even if nobody made it consciously. Make it conscious. Either resource the investigation or accept the defect and say so.
✅
Are quality control standards integrated into the AM inspection routine? Quality control standards that exist as separate documents, checked separately from the CIL and Centreline routine, will be checked separately, and less reliably. The standard belongs in the integrated inspection routine. If it is not there, it is not being confirmed consistently.
✅
Are quality control standards being confirmed through Process Confirmation? A standard that is not confirmed regularly will drift. The frontline leader's Process Confirmation schedule should include quality control standards alongside CIL and Centreline standards. If it does not, the quality standards are being assumed, not confirmed.
✅
Is the defect rate improving on the lines where quality control standards are established? The measure of a quality control standard is whether the defect it addresses is reducing. A standard that has been in place for six months without a measurable reduction in the associated defect type is either wrong, not being followed, or addressing the wrong condition.
✅
Are customer complaints being traced back to internal data? Every complaint should trigger the question: was this defect type visible in the internal data before it reached the customer? If yes, the internal detection system failed. If no, the quality control standard does not cover the condition that produced the defect. Either finding requires action.
✅
Is the Quality pillar team present at AM Step 6 work on each line? Quality control standards built without the Quality pillar team's involvement will be incomplete. The team brings knowledge of which quality parameters are most affected by equipment condition. That knowledge needs to be in the room when the standards are built, not reviewed afterwards.

Where to Start

Before selecting a process to build, take stock of where you are. These questions are not a formal audit. They are a quick read of the quality system as it stands today.

🔍
Do you know your top five defect types by frequency and cost?

If not, start with the Product Defect Matrix. You cannot prioritise investigation work without a clear picture of where the defects are coming from. The matrix is the starting point for everything else in this pillar.

🔍
Are your recurring defect types being investigated to root condition?

If defects are being managed, reworked, adjusted around, or accepted as normal, rather than investigated, start with Quality Defect Investigation on your highest-frequency defect type. Use the six-stage problem solving process. Apply the four conditions as the analysis lens. Find the condition. Remove it.

🔍
Do your operating teams know which equipment settings affect which quality parameters?

If not, the quality control standards for AM Step 6 have not yet been built. This work requires the Quality pillar team, the Maintenance function, and the operating team to work together. The Quality pillar team leads it. It cannot be delegated to AM alone.

🔍
Are quality control standards confirmed through Process Confirmation on a defined schedule?

If not, the standards exist on paper but are not being held in practice. Add quality control standards to the frontline leader's Process Confirmation schedule before the standards drift and the defects return

If the answer to most of these is no, start with Phase 1, Establish. Build the Product Defect Matrix. Run a Quality Defect Investigation on your top recurring defect type. These are the foundations. Without them, quality control standards built at AM Step 6 will not be grounded in the right priorities.

If the matrix exists and investigations are running, but defects are still recurring, start with Phase 2, Strengthen. The most common gap at this stage is not in the tools. It is in the quality control standards, either they do not cover the right conditions, or they are not being confirmed consistently. Fix that before expanding further.

If quality control standards are established, confirmed, and the defect rate is improving, move to Phase 3, Sustain. Extend the standards to all lines. Build the capability across the full Quality pillar team so that investigation and standard-setting work does not depend on one or two people.


Phases

The Quality pillar is introduced in sequence. Each phase builds the capability and the infrastructure that the next one depends on.

Phase 1 — Establish

The Product Defect Matrix is built for the pilot line. The top defect types are identified, classified by severity and frequency, and prioritised for investigation. The Quality pillar team is formed and trained in the six-stage defect investigation process.

At least one Quality Defect Investigation is completed on the pilot line's highest-priority defect type. The investigation uses the four conditions as the analysis lens. The finding changes something, the standard, the equipment condition, the material specification, or the method. The defect does not recur.

Quality control standards are built for the pilot line in partnership with the AM Step 6 work. The Quality pillar team leads this work with the operating team and the Maintenance function. The standards are integrated into the AM integrated inspection routine and confirmed through Process Confirmation.

The measure of Phase 1 is not the defect rate. It is whether the foundations are in place: a current Product Defect Matrix, at least one completed investigation with a confirmed fix, and quality control standards integrated into the AM inspection routine on the pilot line.

Phase 2 — Strengthen

The Product Defect Matrix expands to cover all lines in the pilot area. Quality Defect Investigations are running on the top defect types across the pilot area, led by the Quality pillar team with operations leaders and process owners as active participants.

Quality control standards are built for each line as it reaches AM Step 6. The Quality pillar team supports each line's Step 6 work, ensuring the standards are correct, complete, and integrated into the inspection routine.

The Quality pillar team develops the capability to run investigations independently and to build quality control standards without external support. The measure of Phase 2 is whether the defect rate is improving on the lines where standards are established, and whether investigations are completing with findings that change something.

Phase 3 — Sustain

The Quality pillar's capability reaches all lines and all processes across the site. Quality Defect Investigation is a standard capability, process owners and area leaders can run an investigation without the Quality pillar team leading it. Quality control standards cover all critical quality parameters on all lines and are confirmed through Process Confirmation as a matter of course.

The measure of Phase 3 is not the absence of defects. It is the speed and quality of the response when a defect occurs. A site that has reached Phase 3 does not manage defects. It investigates them, finds the condition, and removes it, consistently, quickly, and without needing to be directed.

The number of people who hold the capability grows across the phases. Phase 1 builds it in the Quality pillar team and the AM pilot team. Phase 2 extends it to the leaders and process owners in the pilot area. Phase 3 reaches all process owners and people leaders across the site.

The depth of capability also grows. In Phase 1, the goal is that the Quality pillar team can run an investigation and build a quality control standard. In Phase 2, the goal is that operations leaders and process owners can participate in and lead investigations. In Phase 3, the goal is that quality defect investigation is embedded, the team closest to the work can define the problem, examine the four conditions, and find the cause without waiting for the Quality pillar team to lead it.

Sample Phase Implementation Plan

Ready to build your pillar?

Before you start, make sure your team is in place, your charter is drafted, and your plan connects to the site's strategic objectives. The Setting Up Your Pillar guide takes you through each step in sequence.